Laminar Separation Bubbles

The performance of almost all model aircraft is strongly influenced by laminar separation bubbles, which may occur at low Reynolds numbers. Such a separation bubble is caused by a strong adverse pressure gradient (pressure rise along the surface), which makes the laminar boundary layer to separate from the curved airfoil surface. The pressure rise is related to the velocity drop towards the trailing edge of the airfoil, which can be seen in the velocity distribution of the airfoil through Bernoulli's equation.

The boundary layer leaves the surface approximately in tangential direction, resulting in a wedge shaped separation area. The separated, but still laminar flow is highly sensitive to disturbances, which finally cause it to transition to the turbulent state. The transition region (not exactly a transition point) is located away from the airfoil at the outer boundary of the separated flow area. The thickness of the now turbulent boundary layer grows rapidly, forming a turbulent wedge, which may reach the airfoil surface again. The region where the turbulent flow touches the surface again is called reattachment point. The volume enclosed by the regions of separated laminar flow and turbulent flow is called a laminar separation bubble. Inside the bubble the flow may be circulating, the direction near the airfoil surface may even be the opposite of the direction of the outer flow. There is almost no energy exchange with the outer flow, which makes the laminar separation bubble quite stable.

Airfoil with Laminar Separation Bubble
Laminar flow, separation bubble and turbulent flow.

The separation bubble thickens the boundary layer and thus increases the drag of the airfoil. The drag increment can be several times the drag of the airfoil without a separation bubble. Lift and Moment are also influenced by a laminar separation bubble, which can lead to problems with stability and control of a model aircraft.

Complete Separation

If the transition occurs quite far away from the airfoil surface, it may happen that the turbulent flow wedge cannot reach the surface again. Thus there is no reattachment and the bubble stays open. Such a flow field with a thick area of separated flow causes a high drag and usually the lift breaks down. The same happens when the angle of attack is increased beyond the maximum lift.

Means to Avoid Separation Bubbles

A very effective means to avoid the drag penalties and nonlinear behavior of lift and moment coefficients, caused by laminar separation bubbles, are turbulators.

Airfoils with reflexed mean lines (as used on flying wing models) suffer stronger from the low Reynolds number effects, because the reflex adds to the pressure gradient in their boundary layer.

Last modification of this page: 08.09.03

[Back to Home Page] Suggestions? Corrections? Remarks? e-mail: Martin Hepperle.

Due to the increasing amount of SPAM mail, I have to change this e-Mail address regularly. You will always find the latest version in the footer of all my pages.

It might take some time until you receive an answer and in some cases you may even receive no answer at all. I apologize for this, but my spare time is limited. If you have not lost patience, you might want to send me a copy of your e-mail after a month or so.
This is a privately owned, non-profit page of purely educational purpose. Any statements may be incorrect and unsuitable for practical usage. I cannot take any responsibility for actions you perform based on data, assumptions, calculations etc. taken from this web page.

© 1996-2006 Martin Hepperle
You may use the data given in this document for your personal use. If you use this document for a publication, you have to cite the source. A publication of a recompilation of the given material is not allowed, if the resulting product is sold for more than the production costs.

This document may accidentally refer to trade names and trademarks, which are owned by national or international companies, but which are unknown by me. Their rights are fully recognized and these companies are kindly asked to inform me if they do not wish their names to be used at all or to be used in a different way.

This document is part of a frame set and can be found by navigating from the entry point at the Web site

Impressum und weitere rechtliche Hinweise für Deutschland